AB Sea Photo
Products and ServicesUsed EquipmentRental EquipmentQuestion and AnswersUnderwater TripsAbout Us.Return Home.
Images provided by David Doubit, Chuck  Davis, Donald Tipton, Mark Strickland, Christopher Newbert

Question:

I am trying to decide which strobe to buy. I want to get one powerful enough to do the job, but I am confused by manufacturers' model numbers and specifications. Can you make any suggestions which will help me decide?

 

 

Can't find what you are looking for? Please contact us so we can find the housing or accessory that you need.

 

Questions and Answers (Q & A's)

From Alan Broder (from Ocean Realm Magazine - May 1995)

Answer:

When I think of the thought process people go through in selecting a strobe for underwater photography, it hearkens me back to when I was a teenager "souping up" my first car engine. When it came to power, there was simply no room for compromise. You went all out for every smidgen of power you could possibly afford. If more carburation meant more power, then the rule was "if some is good - then more must be better; if more is better, then too much must be just right." And so it is for most of us when it comes to selecting a strobe. Our first inclination is to acquire the biggest cotton-picking flamethrower that our significant others will allow us to buy.

You would probably be better off doing a little forward thinking as to what you ultimately want as a total system before buying your first strobe. Basically, there are just two classes of strobes - big strobes and little strobes. There will generally be little more than two f-stops between any member of one class and any member of the other - usually only one stop. Yet their size may differ by a factor of ten, and their power may vary by a factor of several times when measured in watt seconds. The larger strobes use most of their power to cover a larger area with light (usually around 100 degrees) then do the small strobes, which generally cover only about sixty-five to around eighty degrees. It is therefore useful to think of the two classes of strobes that can be used for fish portraits. I unhesitatingly recommend that you buy a macro strobe for macro and a wide-angle strobe for wide-angle. You could us a wide-angle strobe for macro, but it will be clumsy as hell. It will be a major struggle getting it into the tight places where many macro subjects are often found, and it can all but totally obscure any view of whatever it is that you're trying to photograph. It's kind of possible with a housed camera but is a universally recognized form of self abuse when mounted to a Nikonos. You will almost certainly be unable to successfully use a macro strobe for wide-angle since they simply don't have the juice. Of course, some type of shots can be possible when tropical ambient light isn't a factor, but you will generally be attempting wizardry against the tide.

Then how about a "midsize" strobe for macro and wide-angle? Sounds reasonable! The fact is that just about any macro strobe on the market will do the macro deed well. If you have a situation that requires a lot of light, such as a 1:1 shot at f-22 or even f-32 (effective f-stops of forty-five and sixty-four, respectively) on a slow film like Velvia, you can simply move the strobe in closer to the subject. You will increase illumination more effectively and easily this way than by increasing the power of the strobe. Going to a midsize strobe doesn't give you much more light for macro since you probably won't be able to get it in as close. You might reasonably select a midsize strobe for a feature not found on small strobes - a modeling light, for instance. If macro is your game, just pick on with the features you want at the price you like - no problem. Of course, none of this takes the "quality" or "shape" of the light into account, but that's another major question (argument) in itself.

How about using a midsize strobe for wide-angle Using these less powerful strobes to cover a larger area generally leaves you underlit. Using two helps; and for some types of lighting, and lighting in low ambient conditions, this can be adequate. Wide-angle strobe choice, in fact, may lend some credibility to that old adage, "If some is good, more is better . . ." Moving your strobes closer to the subject when more light is needed for a wide-angle shot is usually a poor option. It takes real long arms, and the strobes generally don't look good in the shot. The general rule of thumb is that light falls off roughly an f-stop per foot. A strobe with twice the power will allow you to back up a foot for more coverage or close down a stop for more depth of field.

As to your confusion about comparing manufacturers' model numbers in deciding which strobe will do the job for you, I am at a loss. What's confusing about this? A Nikon SB 104 is more powerful than an SB102, SB103, or SB105. The SB102 is more powerful than the SB103 or SB105. An SB104 is about a stop bright than an Ikelite 150 or a Sea & Sea 200 or 300. The guide number of an Ikelite 300 is within a hair of an SB104 and about a stop brighter than a Sea & Sea 300. The New Ikelite 200 is brighter than the Sea & Sea 200 or 300. Like, what's the problem? You could use the manufacturers' guide numbers, except they lie about guide numbers. Bottom line is that features other than power, such as recycle time, size and weight, factory service, charging characteristics, modeling lights, and of course, the ever popular price consideration, will play a very important part in intelligent strobe selection. Most big strobes will do the big job. I hope everything is clear for you now.

 

 

AB Sea Photo 9136 Sepulveda Blvd., Los Angeles, CA 90045 (2 minutes North of LAX)
Phone: (310)645-8992 Fax (310)645-3645 | Email: info@absea.net Web: http://www.absea.net

Copyright © 2003, AB Sea Photo. All RIGHTS RESERVED.
All trademarks mentioned herein belong to their respective owners.